Otsego Market
HOME
DOUGH
LOCATE
STORY
CONNECT
RECIPES
Otsego Market
HOME
DOUGH
LOCATE
STORY
CONNECT
RECIPES
More
  • HOME
  • DOUGH
  • LOCATE
  • STORY
  • CONNECT
  • RECIPES
  • HOME
  • DOUGH
  • LOCATE
  • STORY
  • CONNECT
  • RECIPES

Our Story: Husband + Wife Team

The Man Behind The Dough

Chef Aaron Pencar: Growing up in Miami, a vibrant culinary and cultural melting pot, Aaron knew from a young age he wanted to be a Chef. Immediately after high school, he pursued a degree in Culinary Arts from Le Cordon Bleu. He has more than 20 years of hands-on experience in upscale concepts from Miami Beach to Boulder. 


Through lots of R&D, Aaron has crafted this Sourdough Pizza Dough as the perfect blend of artisan technique for everyday convenience, and with the support of his wife and business partner - Alexis, they’re thrilled to share this special product with Central New York. 

Where The Magic Happens

Aaron & Alexis, the Co-Founders of Otsego Market, are extremely proud to manufacture and distribute their Sourdough Pizza Dough from their very own commercial kitchen located in Sharon Springs, NY. They are regulated and inspected by New York State Agriculture & Markets and hold an Article 20-C Food Processing Establishment License. 


Otsego Market is grateful for the opportunity to contribute to the local economy and work with regional Retail Partners.

Why Sourdough?

Otsego Market Sourdough Pizza Dough is a delicious & nutritious option and can be a compliment to the bountiful farm fresh goods available in Central & Upstate New York. This Husband & Wife team is on a mission to share their Sourdough Pizza Dough with as many people as possible, while working with, and promoting other local small businesses! 


Follow along on the journey (and more) on social media!

Where to buy our Sourdough Pizza Dough

Find us

Instagram

Connect With Us

Copyright © 2026 Otsego Market - All Rights Reserved.

  • HOME
  • DOUGH
  • LOCATE
  • STORY
  • CONNECT
  • RECIPES